cduce issueshttps://gitlab.math.univ-paris-diderot.fr/cduce/cduce/-/issues2021-05-02T10:41:43+02:00https://gitlab.math.univ-paris-diderot.fr/cduce/cduce/-/issues/17Unsoundness with record typing2021-05-02T10:41:43+02:00Tommaso PetruccianiUnsoundness with record typingFunctions on records can be given unsound types as in the following:
# let f = fun ({..} -> 'a) x -> x;;
val f : Record -> 'a = <fun>
# f {};;
- : 'a = { }
It seems that this `'a` cannot be instantiated:
# (f {}) + 1;;
Characters 1-5:
This expression should have type:
!float | { .. } | Int
but its inferred type is:
'a
which is not a subtype, as shown by the sample:
Atom & 'a
However, here it becomes unsound:
# f (f {});;
- : Empty = { }
Typing of field removal is also unsound:
# let g = fun ({a=Int;b=Bool;..}&'a -> {b=Bool;..}&'a) x -> x\a;;
val g : { a=Int b=Bool .. } & 'a -> { b=Bool .. } & 'a = <fun>
# g {a=2;b=`true};;
- : { a=2 b=`true } = { b=true }
# (g {a=2;b=`true}).a;;
- : 2 = true
# (g {a=2;b=`true}).b;;
- : `true = true
# (g {a=2;b=`true}).a + 2;;
File "runtime/value.ml", line 873, characters 9-15: Assertion failedFunctions on records can be given unsound types as in the following:
# let f = fun ({..} -> 'a) x -> x;;
val f : Record -> 'a = <fun>
# f {};;
- : 'a = { }
It seems that this `'a` cannot be instantiated:
# (f {}) + 1;;
Characters 1-5:
This expression should have type:
!float | { .. } | Int
but its inferred type is:
'a
which is not a subtype, as shown by the sample:
Atom & 'a
However, here it becomes unsound:
# f (f {});;
- : Empty = { }
Typing of field removal is also unsound:
# let g = fun ({a=Int;b=Bool;..}&'a -> {b=Bool;..}&'a) x -> x\a;;
val g : { a=Int b=Bool .. } & 'a -> { b=Bool .. } & 'a = <fun>
# g {a=2;b=`true};;
- : { a=2 b=`true } = { b=true }
# (g {a=2;b=`true}).a;;
- : 2 = true
# (g {a=2;b=`true}).b;;
- : `true = true
# (g {a=2;b=`true}).a + 2;;
File "runtime/value.ml", line 873, characters 9-15: Assertion failedKim NguyễnKim Nguyễnhttps://gitlab.math.univ-paris-diderot.fr/cduce/cduce/-/issues/12Solving type equation with recursive types for a variable 'a does not work wh...2017-10-16T08:48:07+02:00Kim NguyễnSolving type equation with recursive types for a variable 'a does not work when 'a occurs below a union/intersection/negationThe problem is in decompose and solve_rectype in Types. The Positive module giving the least fix point solution of a system of equation (aka Courcelle) does not work when variable occurs below type connective.
See for instance:
```
debug tallying [] [ (Int, 'a),'b ; 'b, 'a ] ;;
```
The problem is in decompose and solve_rectype in Types. The Positive module giving the least fix point solution of a system of equation (aka Courcelle) does not work when variable occurs below type connective.
See for instance:
```
debug tallying [] [ (Int, 'a),'b ; 'b, 'a ] ;;
```
Kim NguyễnKim Nguyễnhttps://gitlab.math.univ-paris-diderot.fr/cduce/cduce/-/issues/9Polymorphic typing of record operations2017-10-16T08:48:07+02:00Kim NguyễnPolymorphic typing of record operationsHow to type the operations on records, concatenation e1 + e2 and field suppression e\ l in the presence of polymorphic variables. For the time being we do a safe but gross approximation. For instance
```
'a & r \ l = r \ l
```
Can we do better?
How to type the operations on records, concatenation e1 + e2 and field suppression e\ l in the presence of polymorphic variables. For the time being we do a safe but gross approximation. For instance
```
'a & r \ l = r \ l
```
Can we do better?