Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
-
- Posts: 163
- Joined: Sat May 17, 2014 8:42 pm
- Location: leland nc
- Motorcycle: 82 goldwing aspencade
82 aspy turned naked (sold)
89 suzuki gsx 1100F
Re: Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
Bench testing is your friend,I learned the hard way verify the needles are seating properly without flooding before you reinstall,and I always turn the petcock off every time I shut down the engine.Too much work (pita) to keep yanking these carbs in and out.
-
- Posts: 439
- Joined: Mon Nov 15, 2010 9:43 pm
- Location: Culpeper, Va
- Motorcycle: 1983 1100 Goldwing Interstate
Re: Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
Update:
OK......While trying to sleep last night I had a revelation or a "what if" regarding that dern white smoke. I thought pretty strongly that it was caused by a super rich mixture on the left side. But all the floats were working (I bench tested and the gas was shutting off on all 4).
So I thought about the fuel pump.......what happens if that fuel pump is pumping at way too high a pressure to the carbs? Why doesnt it have a pressure return back to the gas tank, or some control to limit the gas pressure going to the carbs? I was thinking that if the pressure is too much, then naturally the gas is gonna push and break thru at the weakest spot inside the 4 carbs. And maybe that weak point is one or both carbs on the left side (No 2 and 4).
So I decided to bypass the fuel pump and hook up a gas line straight to the carbs as in this picture: I also had a small container to catch any remaining gas that might pump out of the fuel pump...that is rigged up beside the fuel pump. I cranked her up, and there was absolutely no white smoke coming out of either exhaust. I kept adding more gas to the fuel line and had her running 10-15 minutes, and did not have all that smoking as before. Here is a pic of the exhaust pipes while running:
So my question to the experts........Have you ever seen this happen before? Seems the fuel pump is pushing gas too hard into the carbs. Any fix for this?
OK......While trying to sleep last night I had a revelation or a "what if" regarding that dern white smoke. I thought pretty strongly that it was caused by a super rich mixture on the left side. But all the floats were working (I bench tested and the gas was shutting off on all 4).
So I thought about the fuel pump.......what happens if that fuel pump is pumping at way too high a pressure to the carbs? Why doesnt it have a pressure return back to the gas tank, or some control to limit the gas pressure going to the carbs? I was thinking that if the pressure is too much, then naturally the gas is gonna push and break thru at the weakest spot inside the 4 carbs. And maybe that weak point is one or both carbs on the left side (No 2 and 4).
So I decided to bypass the fuel pump and hook up a gas line straight to the carbs as in this picture: I also had a small container to catch any remaining gas that might pump out of the fuel pump...that is rigged up beside the fuel pump. I cranked her up, and there was absolutely no white smoke coming out of either exhaust. I kept adding more gas to the fuel line and had her running 10-15 minutes, and did not have all that smoking as before. Here is a pic of the exhaust pipes while running:
So my question to the experts........Have you ever seen this happen before? Seems the fuel pump is pushing gas too hard into the carbs. Any fix for this?
-
- Posts: 439
- Joined: Mon Nov 15, 2010 9:43 pm
- Location: Culpeper, Va
- Motorcycle: 1983 1100 Goldwing Interstate
Re: Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
4wred......You are SOOO right.....yanking those carbs in and out is a royal pain. What do you think of my idea that the fuel pump is pushing gas too hard?
- spiralout
- Posts: 1202
- Joined: Sun Feb 17, 2013 6:41 pm
- Location: Alabama
- Motorcycle: 1975 GL1000 (gone)
1980 GL1100I (with '77 1000 engine)
1996 GL1500 SE
Re: Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
Volume flow test your fuel pump. I bet it's within spec.dwight007fchr wrote: Seems the fuel pump is pushing gas too hard into the carbs.
Because with a properly functioning fuel pump and carbs, it doesn't need a return.dwight007fchr wrote: So I thought about the fuel pump.......what happens if that fuel pump is pumping at way too high a pressure to the carbs? Why doesnt it have a pressure return back to the gas tank, or some control to limit the gas pressure going to the carbs? I was thinking that if the pressure is too much, then naturally the gas is gonna push and break thru at the weakest spot inside the 4 carbs. And maybe that weak point is one or both carbs on the left side (No 2 and 4).
Fix your carbs correctly.dwight007fchr wrote: Any fix for this?
- Maz
- Posts: 785
- Joined: Tue May 19, 2015 4:43 am
- Location: Kent, UK
- Motorcycle: 1975 GL1000K1
1976 CB500T
1979 CB750L
1990 Yamaha FJ1200
1993 Suzuki GS500E
Re: Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
I'm really not sure what's going on there, but excess fuel will give you BLACK smoke and a very lumpy idle. Are you sure the fuel in the tank is good, uncontaminated gas? No Seafoam or anything else in it?
Maz
Maz
Ironically, Common Sense is the LEAST common of all senses!
- mytown
- Posts: 213
- Joined: Wed Oct 31, 2012 11:54 am
- Location: Carbondale, Illinois
- Motorcycle: 1982 Goldwing Interstate
Re: Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
Fuel pump, smoke. No fuel pump, no smoke suggests fuel pump to me. Here's a couple of pics from the GL1100 manual that may help with testing it:
Never miss a video: Subscribe to the GoldwingDocs YouTube channel today!
The "original" 25mm float adjustment suggests to me that someone may have tried before to solve your problem and that that float adjustment was a long shot attempt at doing so. I could see trying a lot of things before suspecting the pump. In any case, no smoke is certainly encouraging.
I'd also check what it is that activates the pump such as a cam. Here's a short video of the diaphragm in action:Never miss a video: Subscribe to the GoldwingDocs YouTube channel today!
The "original" 25mm float adjustment suggests to me that someone may have tried before to solve your problem and that that float adjustment was a long shot attempt at doing so. I could see trying a lot of things before suspecting the pump. In any case, no smoke is certainly encouraging.
-
- Posts: 439
- Joined: Mon Nov 15, 2010 9:43 pm
- Location: Culpeper, Va
- Motorcycle: 1983 1100 Goldwing Interstate
Re: Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
Probably Final Update on carb issue:
I was thinking today that since she runs great and without any white smoke by bypassing the fuel pump, then it could have been something as simple as me using that 1/2 gallon jug of gas mounted to the foot peg instead of using the normal fuel tank. I thought that maybe the fuel pump did not have enough resistance in extracting the gas, and with that short fuel line and that jug of gas beside it (and with plenty of air coming into the jug), it was causing the fuel pump pressure to be higher than normal.
So, I went ahead and filled the tank with 5 gallons of fresh non-ethanol and my usual Marvel Super Mystery Oil, and put the correct filter and gas lines back in-line to the fuel pump. Cranked her up, and bingo..........no white smoke at all. Ran her for 10 minutes and there was absolutely none of that whitish smoke. So I am guessing that was the problem......not enough flow resistance by using that 1/2 gallon jug of gas hooked to the fuel pump.
So, got her all dressed up and took her for a short spin (not too far since I just took off the rear calipers and have no rear brakes yet). She sounds and runs great! I love the sportiness of this Wing without all the boxes and fairing add-ons......definately a big difference over the full dresser. Now, gotta get the brakes done so I can drive her a bit before winter sets in.
I was thinking today that since she runs great and without any white smoke by bypassing the fuel pump, then it could have been something as simple as me using that 1/2 gallon jug of gas mounted to the foot peg instead of using the normal fuel tank. I thought that maybe the fuel pump did not have enough resistance in extracting the gas, and with that short fuel line and that jug of gas beside it (and with plenty of air coming into the jug), it was causing the fuel pump pressure to be higher than normal.
So, I went ahead and filled the tank with 5 gallons of fresh non-ethanol and my usual Marvel Super Mystery Oil, and put the correct filter and gas lines back in-line to the fuel pump. Cranked her up, and bingo..........no white smoke at all. Ran her for 10 minutes and there was absolutely none of that whitish smoke. So I am guessing that was the problem......not enough flow resistance by using that 1/2 gallon jug of gas hooked to the fuel pump.
So, got her all dressed up and took her for a short spin (not too far since I just took off the rear calipers and have no rear brakes yet). She sounds and runs great! I love the sportiness of this Wing without all the boxes and fairing add-ons......definately a big difference over the full dresser. Now, gotta get the brakes done so I can drive her a bit before winter sets in.
-
- Posts: 439
- Joined: Mon Nov 15, 2010 9:43 pm
- Location: Culpeper, Va
- Motorcycle: 1983 1100 Goldwing Interstate
Re: Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
mytown.....Thanks for the input and the shop manual references. Yep, when you buy a 35 yr old bike, you never know what the prior owners have done to it in the past. Im just hoping that the carb/fuel pump issue and that whitish smoke is a done deal. Problem solved.....das ve dahyna/adios amigo to the smoke.
Good video of the diaphram in action.....pretty simple style of pump.
MAZ......All the testing done in the past week has been with brand new non-ethanol gas......no Seafoam or Yamalube. In my case, the white smoke was from a super rich mixture.....like No. 4 intake pipe running super cold, and then I found the gas sitting on the bottom of the air box. Maybe the color of the exhaust depends on how clean the cylinder wall is at the time of it running rich? And since this bike has been leaking gas into the cylinders for some time, the cylinder walls and rings may have had all the oil flushed off already? Not sure, but at least she seems good now.
SpiralOut.......Volumne flow testing the fuel pump was gonna be my next step if running her by the fuel tank and not the jug didnt solve the problem. Aye Coptain......I think the carbs are fixed now. If not, I will rip them out and install a high performance triple-wound Tesla Flux Capacitor and go park my Wing in front of the court house during the next thunderstorm.
Good video of the diaphram in action.....pretty simple style of pump.
MAZ......All the testing done in the past week has been with brand new non-ethanol gas......no Seafoam or Yamalube. In my case, the white smoke was from a super rich mixture.....like No. 4 intake pipe running super cold, and then I found the gas sitting on the bottom of the air box. Maybe the color of the exhaust depends on how clean the cylinder wall is at the time of it running rich? And since this bike has been leaking gas into the cylinders for some time, the cylinder walls and rings may have had all the oil flushed off already? Not sure, but at least she seems good now.
SpiralOut.......Volumne flow testing the fuel pump was gonna be my next step if running her by the fuel tank and not the jug didnt solve the problem. Aye Coptain......I think the carbs are fixed now. If not, I will rip them out and install a high performance triple-wound Tesla Flux Capacitor and go park my Wing in front of the court house during the next thunderstorm.
- mytown
- Posts: 213
- Joined: Wed Oct 31, 2012 11:54 am
- Location: Carbondale, Illinois
- Motorcycle: 1982 Goldwing Interstate
Re: Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
Can't argue with success. I was thinking all along how clean the various parts looked. Bike looks clean, sharp, sporty as you say. Wheels look great.
-
- Posts: 439
- Joined: Mon Nov 15, 2010 9:43 pm
- Location: Culpeper, Va
- Motorcycle: 1983 1100 Goldwing Interstate
Re: Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
mytown....Thanks for the thumbs-up on the bike. But as they say, "you cant tell a book by its cover". Nothing seriously wrong, but its amazing how a bike can go downhill real fast when it sits around for years with no maintenance. The rear brakes are seized up, and I pulled them off today and started tearing into them......looked like a severly corroded battery terminal under the rubber boot....both the caliper pistons and the rear master pump cylinder were seized. Brake maintenance is way overlooked by owners.....and I am guilty also. On this bike, I will also tear into the front brakes after seeing how bad the rear ones are.
- RuDogGL
- Posts: 90
- Joined: Mon Oct 30, 2017 9:05 am
- Location: Dixon, CA
- Motorcycle: 1982 GL1100 Interstate GoldWing
- Contact:
Re: Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
Where is the bolt you tighten up to stop the knocking located?
Live Life The Way It Was Meant To Be,
Sin Free
and then
Ride On
The Wings of a GoldWing
GL1100i
Sin Free
and then
Ride On
The Wings of a GoldWing
GL1100i
-
- Posts: 439
- Joined: Mon Nov 15, 2010 9:43 pm
- Location: Culpeper, Va
- Motorcycle: 1983 1100 Goldwing Interstate
Re: Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
Sorry for the long delay in replying......I did not see the post. I am not sure what your question is here. The knocking was caused by the left bank running way too rich. I do not recall one specific bolt that I tightened to stop the knocking. I did use vacuum gauges and synced the carbs, and fixed the rich problem. Runs like a champ now.
-
- Posts: 26
- Joined: Sat Jan 02, 2016 10:20 am
- Location: milk river, alberta, canada
- Motorcycle: 1978 gl1000
Re: Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
do you think he's talking about your ref to the stator nut?
- RuDogGL
- Posts: 90
- Joined: Mon Oct 30, 2017 9:05 am
- Location: Dixon, CA
- Motorcycle: 1982 GL1100 Interstate GoldWing
- Contact:
Re: Fresh carb rebuild and Engine Knocking
Thats is correct spoiledsaskhunter, but I have corrected my issues with the Carbs, I miss cleaning out the fuel mixture jets, so after completing that task all is well.
Live Life The Way It Was Meant To Be,
Sin Free
and then
Ride On
The Wings of a GoldWing
GL1100i
Sin Free
and then
Ride On
The Wings of a GoldWing
GL1100i